A National Approach to Improving Behaviour in Australian Classrooms

19 November 2026

Share this post

Can I say what a pleasure it is to be here at the Centre for Independent Studies in this its 50th year.

The CIS is a powerhouse of Australian policy thought because of the depth and quality of its contributions, and its ability to draw on an extraordinary network of people from all walks of life. It draws on the principles of classical liberalism which are also foundational to the Liberal Party—individual freedom, personal responsibility and property rights.

And it has an enviable record of leading policy debate on education for decades.  

So it’s an honour to be asked to add my own thoughts today.

And I confess there’s another element, too.

Speaking as both the Member for Berowra and Shadow Minister for Education, I feel considerable pride that this extraordinary institution was started by Greg Lindsay a maths teacher, working from his back shed, in a share house, in my own electorate, at 9 Westwood St Pennant Hills.

Today the whereabouts of that famous shed are unknown, which is a great shame, because there are surely few more important relics in the pantheon of Australian classical liberalism. 

It is an honour to be in the presence of Greg Lindsay, Michael Stutchbury, Blaise Joseph and all of the other leading policy minds who have contributed so much to the CIS and to public policy over the past five decades.

It turns out that being a Berowra resident with an interest in education is a powerful combination—though Greg set a high bar for the rest of us!

Context

This afternoon I wanted to speak about a national approach to improving behaviour in Australian classrooms.

Professor Glyn Davis, the former head of the Department of Prime Minister and Cabinet and former Vice Chancellor of Melbourne University, used to quip that ‘all education policy is biography’.

There’s a truth to that.

Our views about education policy are heavily shaped by our own experiences—what worked for us, what failed us, and what we believe schools and educational institutions should provide.

I am a University of New South Wales graduate who comes to this role having worked and taught at the Australian Catholic University, having been a visiting fellow at Harvard’s Kennedy School of Government, and having served on the boards of the Ramsay Centre for Western Civilisation and Teach for Australia.

For me it all started with another Sydney institution, Cranbrook School.

My desire to serve in the Federal Parliament began when I was just ten.

It was my year five teacher, Stephen Lewis, who saw I had an interest in current affairs and suggested I do a project on Australia’s Prime Ministers.

So I wrote a short biography of each Prime Minister and drew a picture of them. 

And when I got to my hero, Sir Robert Menzies, I saw something about the picture I had drawn was not quite right. 

Menzies had these big bushy eyebrows. So being a resourceful ten-year-old, and without my parents’ knowledge, I gave myself a haircut and stuck two big clumps of my hair on the cardboard to represent his eyebrows!  

The point of mentioning this is not just to give you a sense of where I’m coming from when I talk about education policy.

It’s also to take Glyn’s point and invert it.

Because I think it’s also true to say that, at least to some extent, the biography of a nation is a product of its education policy.

If we want a better nation, we need a better education system.

Because right now, the story isn’t good.

The broader problem

Let me give a quick snapshot of the current state of play.

Because although the focus of my remarks today is on classroom behaviour, those remarks need to be put in the context of the broader changes we need to see in school education.

Australia is spending at record levels on school education, but our academic performance has never been worse.

We have just seen lowest ever PISA scores in reading and maths, and the last three years have produced our sharpest drop in performance in a decade.

We are now at the point where 15-year-olds are almost two years behind where they were when John Howard was the Prime Minister.

It’s not about socio-economic status. The sharpest decline in performance in last year’s PISA results was from students in the highest socio-economic quartile.

For the last 15 years or so, we’ve been fed the narrative that educational performance is primarily a question of funding.

Well, the evidence is clear: it’s just not true.

It’s time to get serious. It’s time to move beyond tired old debates about school funding, and refocus on excellence in school education.  

The Coalition’s approach

Two months ago I laid out the Coalition’s plan to restore excellence to Australian schools.

The vision is unashamedly about excellence.

For far too long, we looked at funding, not outcomes. Credentials, and not teacher quality. Sectors, and not students.

Our policy to restore excellence to Australian schools is based on five pillars:

  • The first is curriculum, standards and assessment. This includes drastically simplifying the whole national curriculum to make it shorter, clearer and more usable—starting with the removal of the cross-curriculum priorities. This would give time back to teachers and principals; reduce the burden on states and territories; and allow students to focus much more on foundational knowledge. 
  • The second pillar is teacher workforce and school leadership. This means supporting a return to one-year post-graduate teaching degrees, making it easier for mid-career professionals to become teachers, and exploring new pathways such as supporting veterans to join the profession as a post-service career.
  • The third pillar is around discipline and the school environment. This means that ensuring that classrooms are less disrupted so that learning can take place, and that schools are safe for students and staff. 
  • The fourth is effective teaching methods and education architecture. This includes drastically reducing screen time across the board, limiting the use of AI by students, reducing the education bureaucracy, and lifting boys’ education while keeping strong outcomes for girls.
  • The fifth is around school funding and the costs of education. This means supporting parents to choose the schools that are right for their children and addressing cost and funding pressures as appropriate. It also means the Coalition will honour the levels of school funding in the current bilateral agreements between the Commonwealth and each of the States and Territories. This means ending the funding wars, and neutralising the inevitable Labor lies and scare campaigns before they start

These pillars are interrelated and designed to be mutually supporting.

I take a moment to note that the Greens are not committed to ending the funding wars. They continue to ideologically oppose non-government schools, especially Christian schools.

Today the Greens are pushing the Government to exclude churches, schools, as well as groups like sports clubs, from a charitable carve-out that the Government has designed to protect disbursements to charitable organisations from discretionary trusts.

The Government introduced this carve-out to respond to widespread criticism of the Government’s original blanket approach to trusts which would have seen charitable giving in freefall.

The Coalition opposes the minimum 30% tax on discretionary trusts altogether. However, we are horrified—though not surprised—by the Greens’ attempt to essentially exclude schools and religious entities from legitimate giving. It comes after Labor threatened to end Tax Deductibility Gift Recipient Status to schools in its first term.  

If the Greens’ amendment is accepted by the Government, it would have a significant impact on giving to schools and, inevitably lift fees for all families.

Make no mistake—this is the Greens’ intention.

Anthony Albanese has a choice, to stand up for the millions of families who choose non-government schools, or cave in to the Greens who want to punish them.

This is the test for Anthony Albanese and Labor, and it goes to a bigger issue about the difference between Labor and the Coalition when it comes to supporting parents around schooling.

Because unlike Labor, we in the Coalition are for parental choice.

Unlike Labor, we don’t want to tell parents where to send their children. Parents—not governments—know what’s best for their children.

Unlike Labor, we don’t think families who choose a non-government school are part of a privileged elite.

Unlike Victorian Labor, we will never put a special tax on families sending their children to non-government schools to pay for Labor’s out of control spending.

Unlike Labor, we think parents should be supported if they want to send their children to an Independent or Catholic School.

Unlike the Minister for Education, I won’t tell you that I want one type of school to be ‘parents’ first choice’.

Instead, I want parents to have the widest choice possible.

I want great Government, Catholic and Independent schools.

And I want whatever choice parents make to be a good choice for their family. I want excellence in every Australian school, not just some.

So, while the focus of my remarks today is on classroom behaviour, I wanted to make the point that this is one part of a comprehensive policy that has a broader objective.

And that’s deliberate. Because there is no one silver bullet for restoring excellence to Australian schools.

Classroom disruption and behaviour

So let’s drill down into classroom behaviour, disruption and discipline.

Because the situation is dire.

Let me start by giving just three examples from:

  • PISA, the OECD’s student assessment program;
  • TALIS or the ‘Teaching and Learning International Survey’, which is the OECD’s teacher survey arm; and
  • TIMSS or the Trends in International Mathematics and Science Study (TIMSS) that is run by the International Association for the Evaluation of Educational Achievement

PISA, TALIS and TIMSS – three international measures.

These measures show that the level of classroom disruption and behaviour in Australia is among the highest in the world and that this has a massive impact on learning.

The latest PISA results show us that in science class, 21% of our students are so disrupted that they cannot work well in most or all of their science lessons.

We are now ranked 69th out of 80 countries in terms of our disciplinary climate and disruption in our classrooms.

TIMSS is the same.

The most recent report, from 2023, has some staggering datapoints.

One quarter of year 8 students reported disorderly behaviour in most maths lessons. And there’s a powerful correlation with performance: students in those classes scored 37 points lower than students in classes that were not disrupted.  

It’s not a direct conversion, but we’re talking about more than a year’s learning progress lost.

Correlation is not causation, but that’s a huge gap.

TALIS is the same again. It tells us what teachers themselves are saying.

And they are saying that only 67% of Australian teachers at lower secondary level will substantially achieve their lesson aims in terms of managing student behaviour.

This means one third of teachers are not able to manage student behaviour to the standard they themselves expect.

And almost one in five teachers work in schools where intimidation or verbal abuse of teachers or staff occurs weekly or daily.

Of the 55 systems included in the survey, Australia is the second worst in the world.

But perhaps the most powerful example is not from one of these international surveys, but from the CIS itself.

The headline-grabbing point from the Classrooms in Crisis report that Blaise Jospeh released just a couple of months ago is that Australian teachers lose 9 minutes out of every half hour to classroom disruption – equivalent to 12 weeks a year.

That’s an extraordinary drag on our learning that flows through to workforce, national productivity and broader societal issues.

It’s time for a national approach.

A national approach to behaviour in schools

Today I am calling for discipline and classroom behaviour to be elevated to the national level, and made a priority for our education policy.

Behaviour, discipline, classroom disruption, is a national problem that calls for a national solution.

I’m a federalist at heart.

My instincts are against central planning.

I think things should be resolved at the level closest to the people affected.

I’m not interested in taking over the states’ role in schools.

But I absolutely think there’s room for national leadership.

For a common national direction.

For shared commitment across all governments.

And for coordination across jurisdictions.

So I am calling for a national approach to behaviour in schools.

Because, put simply, regardless of where you are, if the kids aren’t on task, they’re not going to be learning.

If the classroom is disrupted, it won’t matter how good the curriculum is, or how good the facilities are.

That’s the reason the Coalition’s school education policy has behaviour and the classroom environment as one of its key pillars

We are not going to see the academic improvement that we want at the national level unless we also address behaviour.

It is a fundamental determinant of learning. 

And if we want to restore excellence to Australian schools, we need not only to be working from the best available evidence, but also embedding behaviour as a central consideration at every level – from initial teacher training, to professional standards, to support for schools, to culture-setting across the broader community, and as a priority for our national education institutions.

Let me talk through those measures in turn.

A national behaviour survey

The first commitment I make today is simple: a national survey of student behaviour, across all jurisdictions and all sectors.

This is all about evidence-based policy.

Across Australia right now there is no consistent, reliable measure of classroom disruption and behaviour that provides an evidence base on which to measure reforms.

It’s no accident that 3 of the 4 data sources I mentioned a few minutes ago were international measures and the fourth was run by the CIS.

There’s a basic truism that you cannot manage what you cannot see. And if you put it a little more forcefully: what is measured is managed.

The basic point is that if we are going to improve behaviour in our schools, we need a reliable evidence base.

The need for this type of measure is obvious. As I said when the CIS released Blaise Joseph’s excellent paper:

We need a reliable national baseline to understand its scale, including the cumulative impact of low-level disruption

A national behaviour survey allows all of us—governments at federal, state and territory level, school systems, schools and policy makers—to identify areas most at risk, to measure what works and design future interventions.

A national behaviour survey builds a national baseline, and provides the crucial longitudinal data that we need if we’re going to improve our system into the 2030s and 2040s.

That’s why it was part of the education policy that my friend Sarah Henderson took to the last election.

What I expect the national survey will show is a confirmation of some of the trends we are seeing in the international measures:

  • that our classrooms are disrupted;
  • that it’s both a learning issue and a safety issue;
  • that young women in the teaching profession are often particularly targeted;
  • that different schools in different areas will have different needs; and
  • that in too many cases behaviour management is inadequately taught in Initial Teacher Education degrees.

But until we can put some numbers around it, we are hamstrung in designing effective policy interventions that are targeted and scaled appropriately. As I said, you can’t manage what you cannot see.

Restoring the link between funding and performance in ITE

The second measure I want to talk about today is restoring the link between funding and performance in Initial Teacher Education.

It has been clear for years now that far too many teachers have been let down by their initial teacher education at university.

That they have not been adequately equipped to manage the classroom.  

That’s was why, five and a half years ago, in April 2021, Alan Tudge launched the Quality Initial Teacher Education or ‘QITE’ review.

That’s where we saw very clear recommendations to deal with the continued and ongoing resistance to phonics, explicit instruction and practical instruction in behaviour management.

The QITE review made two specific recommendations which Jason Clare adopted – around strengthening core content and accreditation, and around linking performance and funding of ITE.

Those two recommendations led directly to Mark Scott’s Strong Beginnings report and, in turn, the agreement by Education Ministers in 2023 to introduce core content into teaching degrees.

The core content was meant to embed phonics, explicit instruction and behaviour management skills in our teacher training.

But last week we had the revelations, reported by Lucy Carroll, that after three years and despite the assurances to the contrary, some universities are discouraging explicit teaching, and some universities are using the discredited “whole language” approach to reading instead of phonics. Institutions which resisted explicit teaching were nevertheless marked as having teacher training of ‘sufficient’ quality.

And we don’t really know how widespread the problem is.

Because of the 280-odd teacher education courses across the country, which train between 15 and 17 thousand teachers every year, ITE Quality Assurance Oversight Board only looked at 16 of them.

It’s quite shocking really.

If that’s the approach to phonics and pedagogy in the universities, what confidence do we have in their ability to train teachers in classroom management?

Let me ask the basic question: if these universities do not meet the minimum standards for initial teacher education that have been agreed by Education Ministers, why are we funding them?

Why are we allocating them Commonwealth supported places which are paid for by the taxpayer?

What’s the incentive to improve – particularly in the managed growth era, where universities no longer compete to attract students?

I’m not interested in beating up on teachers. I think they do a great job in a complex environment.

But I have no time for academic institutions which refuse to give up faddish pet theories or ignore the evidence around best practice.

Almost 5 years ago the QITE review said that we should, quote, ‘strengthen the link between performance and funding of ITE’, and that we should allocate CSPs based on ITE performance.

It’s time to revisit that recommendation.

This can be done tomorrow through a direction to the ATEC around the preferential allocation of Commonwealth supported places to universities that effectively implement content around behaviour management and other core skills.

And I’m open to other measures too – like beefing up the ITE Quality Assurance Oversight Board, or establishing a National Inspector of ITE to stop the university leaders from weaselling out of change.

Because after all, if the universities responsible for training our teachers aren’t setting them up for success, aren’t giving principals what they need, and aren’t even implementing basic standards around teacher training, why should Australian mums and dads keep paying for them?

Let the message go forward to the universities: no phonics no funding.

A national behaviour framework for schools

The third measure I want to talk about is around behavioural expectations.

If we are serious about addressing behaviour and disruption at a national level, it’s time we looked at a National Behaviour Framework for Schools.

This builds on the commitments I’ve made previously about supporting communities at the individual school level to develop statements of behavioural expectations.

A National Behaviour Framework for Schools should set out core principles that are designed to reinforce the basics of effective teaching—like setting baseline expectations, predictable routines and structured lessons to support effective learning—and should be supported by practical guidance materials and practical examples.

This would allow the framework to be contextualised to the specific school community.

Because although there are always common principles—like respect for teachers—the way you implement it in Cranbourne or Kalgoorlie might differ from the way you implement it in Cairns.

But a national framework is never going to be enough on its own.

Because education is not just about governments and not just about schools. Education is a contract between teachers, parents, schools and students. That means there are responsibilities on all sides.

Behaviour is a learning issue.

Behaviour is a safety issue.

But behaviour is not the responsibility of teachers and principals alone. 

If we are going to implement a National Behaviour Framework for schools standards, it is going to require the commitment and endorsement from all parts of the community.

That means students, and it means parents too.

Two months ago, when I raised the prospect of supporting schools across the country to develop statements of behavioural expectations, I spoke quite deliberately about backing teachers and principals to enforce them.

This is about signalling and culture-setting across the broader community.

I’ve lost count of the number of times I’ve heard teachers talk about things like a basic refusal to accept accountability by parents. About undermining school authority and outsourcing basic discipline to teachers. And in the worst cases, about verbal abuse and hostility.

I am calling for us as a nation to make a conscious commitment to supporting teachers and principals when it comes to discipline and behaviour.

Let me put my role as Shadow Minister and Representative to the side for one minute, and speak as a father of two in the education system.

We as parents must do our part.

All of us.

If we want better outcomes from our schooling system, we need better behaviour in our classrooms.

And if we want better behaviour in our classrooms, it starts with the mums and dads.

It starts with building a culture of respect for teachers and for principals., and it starts at home.

Now of course there are those who need help – and they should get it. I can’t think of a single parent I know who wants their child to be disruptive. But this isn’t about blame.

What I am calling for is essentially recognition, at a national level:

  • that we all have an interest in better school outcomes for our children;
  • that that means we need better behaviour in our classrooms, and embracing, strong, positive classroom cultures across the board; and
  • that we all have responsibilities to help build that culture in our own school communities.

What I am saying is that we cannot individualise a systemic problem. We cannot push it all onto the teacher in the classroom.

It needs to be broader. It needs to be a conscious, collective effort. A systemic problem needs a systemic solution. It needs leadership and endorsement at the national level.

A Coalition government will play its part.

As a parent, I am prepared to do my part too.

And I am asking Australians across the board to join me.

A benchmark for the Teaching and Learning Commission

The fourth measure I want to talk about today is about how we embed behaviour as a priority in our national institutions.

Right now there are four education bodies at the national level which are responsible for schools, outside the Federal Department of Education.

We have:

  • ACARA, the Australian Curriculum, Assessment and Reporting Authority, which self-evidently deals with curriculum and assessment;
  • AITSL, the Australian Institute for Teaching and School Leadership, which is meant to look after teacher standards;
  • Education Services Australia or ESA, which looks after the technology and infrastructure; and
  • AERO, or the Australian Education Research Organisation, which is about research.

The government is consulting now on how to collapse those four bureaucracies into a single body called the Teaching and Learning Commission or TLC.

Reportedly, this is not so much about losing their functions, but rolling them into a single body.

We will see what the government puts on the table and make our judgement accordingly. With Labor, the devil is always in the detail and you never know what you’re going to get.

I am sick of stakeholders coming to me and telling me they were shown a slide-deck and a non-disclosure agreement, only for legislation to be introduced in a way that’s riddled with unintended consequences.

We had a prime example of this silliness recently with Labor’s university funding legislation.

They kept it secret, then introduced it, then realised it was so full of avoidable errors that they had to amend their own legislation in the House, then in the Senate, and then in the House again.

So I won’t make a commitment to supporting or not supporting any particular piece of legislation until it’s been through ordinary party room processes and ordinary parliamentary scrutiny.

And in the meantime, I’d encourage Jason Clare to pursue the exposure draft process that he’s so far avoided.

But there are a couple of general principles that I think are worth noting.

First, I’m from the side of politics that’s against red tape.

I generally don’t think that changing the shape of bureaucracies is a noteworthy policy achievement.

I don’t buy the hype about this deck-chair shifting being a revolution in school education. It’s not.

But I do generally think reducing the number of bureaucracies is a good thing. So when it comes to the TLC, that’s a good start.

But more importantly, I cannot see how the TLC can succeed as an entity designed to govern the teaching sector if it doesn’t deal with issues of behaviour.

So let me set a couple of benchmarks.

First, the teaching and learning commission must deal with behaviour in the same way it deals with assessment, curriculum and reporting.

This is once again about sending a clear signal around national priorities.

Second, the commission must complete the work on reforming teacher professional standards.

AITSL’s teacher standards should have been rewritten years ago, but that simply has not happened.

The current standards are more than 15 years old and I think it’s fair to say there is a broad consensus for the way they are out of date and do not deal appropriately with behaviour and disruption.

Thinkers like Dr Tim McDonald, Greg Ashman, Caiti Wade and even AITSL itself have listed a range of concerns.

They are open to being criticised by for being vague, career-based descriptors that are insufficiently specific to support reliable assessment.

For dealing poorly with frequent low-level disruption.

For focusing on responses to disruption, rather than emphasising routines and instructional techniques that prevent it.

For encouraging approaches that are based on negotiation instead of clear and consistent boundaries.

For failing to adequately protect the learning of other students.

For lagging behind the core content that is now meant to be implemented in initial teacher education.

For being out of touch with the modern reality when it comes to digital distraction and disruption.

The new Teaching and Learning Commission is about to inherit responsibility for teacher standards.

This new body must be given the latitude – indeed the obligation – to make those standards fit for purpose, especially in relation to behaviour and classroom management.

After all, the standards don’t just inform new teachers, but the whole ecosystem of professional development and improvement that lifts teacher quality over time.

The new Teaching and Learning Commission must embed behaviour a priority, and it must ensure that teachers, school leaders and others are equipped and supported to build the classroom behaviours we need.

Anything less will be a fail.

Conclusion

Classroom behaviour is national problem.

Disrupted classrooms, poor behaviour and discipline issues affect students, teachers, parents, productivity, the national economy and arguably some of the demographic and population shifts we are seeing across the board.

This is a national issue. It’s in all of our interests to address it.

We need to build the evidence base.

Gather the data.

Insist on improvements to our teacher education.

Reform the professional standards.

Embed behaviour as a priority in our national institutions.

And start the cultural shift across the broader community that links parental responsibility to respect for teachers and a better classroom environment for our kids.

Then we can go some way to restoring excellence to Australians schools.

Thank you.

Latest news

19 November 2026

A National Approach to Improving Behaviour in Australian Classrooms

Can I say what a pleasure it is to be here at the Centre for Independent Studies in this its ...

19 September 2026

Address to Education for Human Flourishing Conference

Well, can I say, Ben, thank you so much for having me this morning. I’ve never quite had an introduction ...

8 September 2026

Address to the ACSES Policy Symposium: The evolving student in higher education

Good morning, It’s a privilege to be able to address the ACSES policy symposium, and I’m sorry I’m not able ...